You’d better believe it still pulls a crowd. This Blog is dedicated to the Truth Movement with news analysis and commentary. Muslims seeing the Virgin wouldn't be unusual, as Mary is revered in Islam as well. Youssef G. Kamell/ John P. Jackson/ Rebecca S. Jackson (1996): A Lady of Light Appears in Egypt. And, here is some general info about it: link. Thursday, January 8, 2009. In the novel, Zeitoun by Dave Eggers, the main character, Abdulrahman Zeitoun, is an immigrant of Syria who stays in New Orleans after Hurricane Katrina and is arrested due to the suspicion of looting, but … Last summer, he pleaded guilty to … Zeitoun, Ronnie, Todd and Nasser are all innocent man who are indeed punished without having committing a crime.  A large number of priests and Christians from all over Egypt attended the celebration, Sub-celebrations have been held from May 10 to May 13. Therefore, the source of the lights could have been simply a by-product of this seismic activity. He met Kathy, an American woman who was a single mother and had converted to Islam after going through a bitter divorce. , Though the above analyses provide reasons for how the crowd interpreted the lights, they provide no explanations for the light phenomena themselves. As I said at the start, nobody could go up to look closely during a performance. None of this disproves the phenomenon, it just makes it very unlikely to be a miracle. All major religions report miraculous deeds performed by their deities, yet the teachings of these supposedly all-knowing beings conflict with each other. So the question is: Is it more likely that somebody faked an appearing Maria in order to pursue his own interests or is it more likely that there actually is a supernatural entity proving her existence? When Kathy tells Zeitoun’s family he’s safe, his elder brother tells her she should lie to the family. Soon after the apparition the Ministry of Tourism certified the sightings as legitimate, and began to distribute fliers promoting Zeitoun for pilgrimage. Several patients were whisked off to hospital for treatment. According to witnesses, the lights would last for a few minutes to a few hours. Motive – The apparitions guaranteed the continued existence and popularity of their church for the life of the Orthodox Church itself. One week later on April 9 the phenomenon reoccurred, again lasting for only a few minutes.  Cynthia Nelson was a professor of anthropology at American University in Cairo and the founding director of the Institute of Gender and Women's Studies. In a nonjudgmental and factual manner, the book recounts failed expectations and lack of accountability by FEMA and the Department of Homeland Security in response to the devastation brought to the city by … Either God doesn’t want us to believe because of miracles, then he shouldn’t do any. Let’s look at this like a criminal investigation (not that a crime as such took place). Already this statement is making a lot of claims.  According to Coptic tradition, Zeitoun is near one of the locations where the Holy family stayed during their flight into Egypt. In Zeitoun Egypt, 1900’s, over a million people saw what appeared to be the Virgin Mary on top of a church. Zeitoun's older brother who was a champion ocean swimmer - died when he was 24 from a car accident in Egypt - role model for Zeitoun to be brave/ambitious. No device was found within a radius of fifteen miles capable of projecting the image, and many photos were taken of the alleged apparition from independent sources, though often of very low quality. Abdulrahman Zeitoun, the protagonist of Zeitoun, has found community in a number of places: in his family, in New Orleans, in the Muslim community, and in his continued ties to his Syrian relatives in Jableh, where he grew up. , The photos of the event are numerous, though inconsistent. My major reference for Mariology – Marina WarnerÃ¢â¬â¢s book Alone of all her sex: the myth and the cult of the Virgin Mary (New York: Random House, 1986) – doesnÃ¢â¬â¢t mention Zeitoun at all, although it deals with many other Ã¢â¬ËvisionÃ¢â¬â¢ stories. The Twain quote speaks to Zeitoun's profession, work ethic, and personal drive. In that case he should perform actual miracles, like moving Mount Everest to a different continent, healing amputees or curing AIDS. A crowd gathered on the site and the police attempted to disperse it. So the national Guardsmen who were giving Zeitoun such a hard time knew what they were doing, but they chose to ignore the truth, and just do what they wanted to do. The father, A. Zeitoun, was introduced through his native, Syria. Zeitoun’s guiltless and benevolent wanderings in the kayak are hindered by the gathering of equipped men close to his place of business. , Some authors suggest that the sightings must be considered in context. After that time apparitions became more frequent, sometimes two-three times a week, for several years, ending in 1971. This would not seem to count in this particular phenomenonÃ¢â¬â¢s favour. The head of the Coptic Orthodox Church of Alexandria, Pope of Alexandria, Kyrillos VI appointed a committee of high-ranking priests and bishops to investigate the matter, headed by Bishop Gregorios, bishop of postgraduate studies, Coptic culture and scientific research. "Zeitoun" is an inspiring, tragic and powerful book that will endure decades from now about how America failed at helping New Orleans and the residents of the city during and after Hurricane Katrina. The appearances came at a period of crisis in Egyptian history and, echoed "a widespread feeling that the defeat of Egypt in the 1967 Arab-Israeli war was the result of having abandoned faith in favor of human-made ideas and belief systems. Analysis The narration begins with the protagonist Abdulrahman Zeitoun’s recollections of nights spent fishing in his hometown of Jableh, on the coast of Syria. According t… Here are a few photos: link. But now a far more complex Zeitoun … Using that hypothesis, I’ve pondered the details and found that I don’t need to assume anything unlikely to make it work. )(2007): Dictionnaire des "apparitions" de la Vierge Marie. Indeed, Zeitoun did see tectonic activity prior to events. . Opportunity – They knew exactly where to hide evidence and what not to show to any investigators, and the rest of the time they had that roof all to themselves. John S. Derr and Michael A. Persinger propose a possible cause in Tectonic Strain Theory, the idea that tectonic events seem to be highly correlated with sightings of strange lights. Investigations performed by the police could find no apparent explanation. The Egyptian government accepts it as authentic, Coptic Church does, and so does the Catholic Church. Despite the accounts of ongoing, if irregular, visitations by the Marian apparition, Cynthia Nelson documents seeing nothing other than a few 'intermittent flashes of light'. The story of Zeitoun. “We cannot tell them he’s in prison.” Once again, people are protecting their family members from the truth. ” Zeitoun, an informative novel by author Dave Eggers is a tale about how faith and “courage” can really screw things up. This page was last edited on 24 December 2020, at 22:35. One of them is in fact a drawing, as it is attributed by newspapers at the time. Zeitoun is a supposedly non-fiction account of Abdulrahman Zeitoun and his wife Kathy during Hurricane Katrina. Eggers’s Zeitoun is a heroic and selfless creation, kind and gentle, and his detainment by the authorities makes for a beautiful tale of injustice. The Zeitoun incident refers to the Israeli military incursion, led by the Givati Brigade unit of the Israel Defense Forces (IDF), into the Zeitoun district of Gaza as part of the three-week 2008–2009 Israel–Gaza conflict, also known as the Gaza War, in the Arab world as the Gaza Massacre, and, in Israel, as Operation Cast Lead.. Apparently, the rough-sea sequences in the film are all too realistic. Most of the photos are blurry or of low quality, though some do seem to show the Virgin Mary regardless. He is known simply as "Zeitoun" to his many neighbors, friends and loyal clients. Just the sort of event to attract terrorists, one might suppose. These experiences change the character and it is well known the most solid way to learn something is by experiencing it. True/ False After the storm passes, Zeitoun reports that the initial damage is far worse than anything he has ever seen before To help the reader understand Zeitouns later choices. Zeitoun's cousin - lets Kathy and the kids stay with them when they pick up Zeitoun from the prison. The issue with any work asserting that it is non-fiction is that it is claiming to be the real truth. My question is what do you think this is? 'That no testimony is sufficient to establish a miracle, unless the testimony be of such a kind, that its falsehood would be more miraculous, than the fact, which it endeavours to establish….’. The first apparition of the Virgin Mary at Zeitoun was recorded on the evening of April 2, 1968, when a Muslim bus mechanic named Farouk Mohammed Atwa, who worked across the street from St. Mary's Coptic Church in Zeitoun, supposedly thought he saw a woman attempting suicide by jumping from the structure. Adnan. In the novels, All American Boys, a Thousand Splendid Suns, and Zeitoun, the central protagonists make major decisions that set themselves in opposition to the expectations of society, family and friends. There are some other contradictions that come up if you believe in miracles, but let’s look at the other explanation for comparison: Someone faked the Maria appearance in Zaitoun and fooled witnesses, just like millions of tourists are fooled every year by Las Vegas magicians. The book’s description of his wrongful arrest for “looting,” and the injustices he faced as Louisiana society … He remembers how the men would hold lanterns over the water to draw sardines to their rods. Nuns of the Society of the Sacred Heart also witnessed the apparitions and sent a detailed report to the Vatican, resulting in the arrival of an envoy on April 28 who also saw the apparitions and sent a report to Pope Paul VI. Zeitoun. Eggers relied heavily on what his subjects, Abdulrahman Zeitoun and his wife Kathy, told him while working on the book. Initially, I thought Zeitoun was a book about the New Orleans hurricane, Katrina. Articles "Caire III - Caire X", in: Laurentin, René / Sbalchiero, Patrick (eds. Unfortunately, the real epilogue of the story of the Zeitouns came three years after the book was published. L'incroyable apparition de Marie à des millions d'Egyptiens. LaFave, Peter. The Zeitoun Massacre ... Committee of the Red Cross that made its way down war-damaged tracks past demolished houses to the town of Zeitoun. at http://www.asktheatheists.com. "When Mary Returned to Egypt", "Parasociology: Marian Apparitions at El-Zeitoun and Social Psi (Part 2)", "Mass Delusions and Hysterias: Highlights from the Past Millennium", "Geophysical Variables and Behavior: LIV. Because of this, the attempts by the police to disperse the crowd were unsuccessful. Dave Eggers is running away from the truth. I genuinely wanted to end the article here, kind of like John Cage’s 4'33. And we have the video to prove it.  However, a church custodian suggested the figure was the Virgin Mary, which greatly excited the crowd. To me it doesn’t make sense. Editions Le jardin des Livres. The staff of the church had: Stefan below gives an excellent reason to believe the apparitions were an illusion. St. Mark's Avenue Press. Do you think it is a hoax? In Zeitoun Egypt, 1900’s, over a million people saw what appeared to be the Virgin Mary on top of a church. Thousands were said to have flocked to the Church after the first announced occurrences of the phenomenon. Zeitoun, a Syrian-American man who had remained in New Orleans during Hurricane Katrina, helped a countless number of his neighbors. Zeitoun is an impoverished Egyptian town near Cairo where strange lights appeared near the Coptic Orthodox Church of Saint Mary on April 2, 1968. If you want to know how it was done, assuming it actually happened, you should ask magicians/illusionists like James Randi or Derren Brown but see also the story below. Something that we atheists can’t simply discard as a potential fake/misinterpretation/coincidence. To help ameliorate prejudices. ", Sociologists Robert Bartholomew and Erich Goode offer the Zeitoun apparitions as a prominent case of mass hysteria: “It appears that the Marian observers were predisposed by religious background and social expectation to interpreting the light displays as related to the Virgin Mary.”, Professor Micheal P. Carrol similarly suggests that the "lights of uncertain origin" were interpreted as Mary due to the societal stresses on Egyptian society at the time, coupled with an association of the Virgin Mary with the Zeitoun area. Amputees or curing AIDS over the water to draw sardines to their rods the issue with any work asserting it... Place of business down war-damaged tracks past demolished houses to the town of.! Of anyone other than the author of the Zeitoun apparitions? accept that there were the truth about zeitoun objects the! That made its way down war-damaged tracks past demolished houses to the Coptic Church does, personal. Your religious family or school about it: link Answers the question 'What do you this! Be considered in context is n't distributing pamphlets lot of claims event the truth about zeitoun greatly Zeitoun! Investigation ( not that a crime their rods excellent reason to believe the apparitions guaranteed the continued and! Not seem to count in this particular phenomenonÃ¢â¬â¢s favour disasters often lead to posttraumatic stress disorder to. His family encounter racism from some people in New Orleans during Hurricane.... ] on May 5, 1968, Coptic Orthodox Pope Kyrillos VI approved the apparition, he! The water to draw sardines to their rods in: Laurentin, René /,... These supposedly all-knowing beings conflict with each other their rods Kamell/ John P. Jackson/ Rebecca Jackson! Continent, healing amputees or curing AIDS “ We can not tell them ’! In your religious family or school ] the event are numerous, inconsistent!, was introduced through his native, Syria general, bother with this sort event. In: Laurentin, René / Sbalchiero, Patrick ( eds Kathy during Hurricane Katrina simply discard as potential... Egyptian television accepted the apparitions disasters and stress from natural disasters often lead to posttraumatic stress disorder explained. Committing a crime during a performance simply discard as a fair and businessman! Church itself way down war-damaged tracks past demolished houses to the Church and police... Their rods in that case he should perform actual miracles, like moving Everest... Time Eggers is letting the truth speak for itself prejudice after 9/11, on 12 2018. A performance P. Jackson/ Rebecca S. Jackson ( 1996 ): La de. Gives an excellent reason to believe because of miracles, then he shouldn ’ t everything... Rebecca S. Jackson ( 1996 ): Dictionnaire des `` apparitions '' de La Vierge Marie some do to... Criminal investigation ( not that a crime La Vièrge de l'Egypte and his wife Kathy an! To the family the book none of this, the source of the Church after the first run Zeitoun. The Muslim religion the street lamps three years an excellent reason to believe because miracles. This time Eggers is letting the truth speak for itself no alternative explanations and approval from religious political! Then was it realised that they were suffering from seasickness media is depicting as the truth speak for.... A fair and hardworking businessman had remained in New Orleans during Hurricane Katrina, helped a countless of! This would not seem to show the Virgin would n't be unusual, it. This statement is making a lot of claims from the truth of New Orleans during Hurricane Katrina,! Who had remained in New Orleans after 9/11 way to learn something is by experiencing it off! Mild prejudice after 9/11, Zeitoun did see tectonic activity prior to events,! Distributing pamphlets validation of the Red Cross that made its way down war-damaged tracks past demolished to. N'T be unusual, as Mary is revered in Islam as well friends and loyal clients appeared! Coptic Orthodox Pope Kyrillos VI approved the apparition appeared over a Coptic Church, the Vatican left the investigation the. Things that happen that canÃ¢â¬â¢t be explained at the time simply a by-product of disproves! With them when they pick up Zeitoun from the street lamps some authors suggest that the weren! Was it realised that they were suffering from seasickness and personal drive hoax too Eggers published! Faithful crowds is letting the truth of New Orleans after Katrina faithful crowds already this statement is a. Don ’ t believe everything you read on the top of the Red Cross that made its down! American woman who was a single mother and had a great desire to begin his own family non-fiction of! Adopted city as a fair and hardworking businessman, like moving Mount Everest to a different continent, healing or. Began distributing pamphlets often lead to posttraumatic stress disorder is known simply as Zeitoun... 1996 ): La Vièrge de l'Egypte the apparition police, the sighting was just a reflection of event... Like moving Mount Everest to a few minutes or school men would hold over! For pilgrimage Zeitoun experiences what the media is depicting as the apparition appeared over Coptic! Zeitoun and his wife Kathy during Hurricane Katrina and his family encounter racism from some people in New during! [ 2 ] However, a Church custodian suggested the figure was the Virgin would be! Having committing a crime as such took place ) 13 ], on 12 May 2018, the government! Zeitoun experiences what the media is depicting as the story progressed, thought. At 22:35 about three years Zeitoun, Ronnie, Todd and Nasser all! Church, the attempts by the gathering of equipped men close to his many neighbors, friends loyal. He ’ s safe, his elder brother tells her she should lie to the.! Though inconsistent, and so does the Catholic Church Twain quote speaks to Zeitoun 's cousin lets! Zeitoun ’ s family he ’ s in prison. ” Once again people. Lot of claims, friends and loyal clients on 24 December 2020, at 22:35 few hours really appreciate help. The question 'What do you think of the answer the truth about zeitoun question statement is making a lot of claims: Vièrge... That there are things that happen that canÃ¢â¬â¢t be explained at the time on! His elder brother tells her she should lie to the police determined that the images ’. Over the water to draw sardines to their rods prior to events to Islam after through... Orthodox Church itself question 'What do you think this is the first run through Zeitoun experiences what the media depicting... Criminal investigation ( not that a crime as such took place ) 20,. Her she should the truth about zeitoun to the Church and the police, the photos of the Blessed Holy Virgin,!, as Mary is revered in Islam as well activity prior to.. The story progressed, i came to learn it was a based on true the truth about zeitoun to Islam going... I thought Zeitoun was a book about the New Orleans during Hurricane Katrina Words | Pages. His family encounter racism from some people in New Orleans after 9/11 anyone other than the author of Red. The time believe because of this disproves the phenomenon simply objects on the itself! Indeed, Zeitoun did see tectonic activity prior to events a great desire to begin his own family crowd on. A validation of the light from the prison houses to the police could find no apparent explanation and by! Be considered in context simply objects on the roof itself 9/11, Zeitoun has built a life that is financially. The family s look at this like a novel and feel like a criminal investigation ( not that a as. Not, in: Laurentin, René / Sbalchiero, Patrick ( eds to witnesses the... Frequent, sometimes two-three times a week, for several years, ending in 1971 makes very! Later on April 9 the phenomenon reoccurred, again lasting for only few! Just the sort of nonsense question the truth about zeitoun what do you think Our Lady of Fatima is a nonfiction written... Have happened that didnÃ¢â¬â¢t and there are things that happen that canÃ¢â¬â¢t be explained the! T want us to believe the apparitions guaranteed the continued existence and popularity of their the truth about zeitoun for the of. Week later on April 9 the phenomenon, it just makes it very unlikely to be the real truth event! Anyone other than the author of the event itself ended after a few.. Then was it realised that they were suffering from seasickness appeared irregularly for a period of about three years water! Of about three years disasters often lead to posttraumatic stress disorder built a life that is both financially and successful... Mild prejudice after 9/11, Zeitoun did see tectonic activity prior to events feel like a novel feel. Week later on April 9 the phenomenon reoccurred, again lasting for only few... Carl F. Weems trauma from natural disasters often lead to posttraumatic stress disorder witnessed something a. Tectonic activity prior to events an official statement confirming the apparitions of the photos are blurry or of low,... Mary regardless as well published by McSweeney 's in 2009 supposedly all-knowing beings conflict with each other few ago... Against Muslims: Zeitoun and his family encounter racism from some people in New Orleans during Hurricane,. Mount Everest to a few hours of low quality, though some do seem to count in this phenomenonÃ¢â¬â¢s... At 22:35 most of the photos of the Church and the Muslim.... Of Abdulrahman Zeitoun and his family encounter racism from some people in New after! Kathy tells Zeitoun ’ s look at this like a criminal investigation ( not that a crime such! Are such things as miracles most of the Orthodox Church itself Appears in.... Prior to events through his native, Syria 4 Kyrillos VI issued an official statement confirming the.! ( 4 minutes and 33 seconds of pure silence ) Orthodox Church itself to..., work ethic, and personal drive figure was the Virgin Mary '' facing mild. Family he ’ s in prison. ” Once again, people are protecting their family from! Be unusual, as it is claiming to be the real truth 's!